*Gluten Friendly options are now available. Contact your local store for flavors and availability.*

Southern Custard


Smooth, mild, and sweet, our buttermilk filling is like a cross between a chess pie and a custard.


Pecans, chocolate chips, a sprinkle of toasted coconut, and a smooth pecan pie filling combined in a sweet shortbread crust.

Granny’s apple

Passed down for generations, this pie harkens back to a simpler time when food was fresh, homemade, and created by someone you knew.

chocolate cream

This classic favorite is filled with thick and rich chocolate custard in our signature Oreo crust, topped with lightly sweetened fresh whipped cream, and garnished with chocolate shavings.

key lime

Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling.

peanut butter cream

Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust.

coconut cream

Rich, creamy, and with a taste like summer, our Coconut Cream Pie is one that can be enjoyed no matter the season.

chewy chocolate chip

Brown sugar, chocolate chips and vanilla combined and baked into a buttery shortbread crust.


Lemon Icebox

Bring on the sunshine with this sweet and citrusy Spring favorite reminiscent of fresh squeezed lemonade.


thumbprint cookies

Housemade shortbread, with our perfectly sweet icing.

cloud 9

Our signature take on pie a la mode. We combine a mini pie with a scoop of ice cream so you get pie and ice cream in every bite.


9-inch pies

Perfect for birthdays family gatherings and corporate gifting.
Serves 7-9

4-inch pies

Great for personal indulgence, gifts, and team celebrations.
Boxed individually, four pack, and by the dozen

2-inch pies

You get three each of Key Lime, Chocolate Cream, I-40, and Chewy Chocolate Chip packaged together in one box.

Boxed by the dozen

pie stack

Ideal for parties, meetings and thoughtful gifts. Wrapped in cellophane and personalized with ribbon and tag.

Available in stacks on 1, 2, or 3

Pie and Perks!

Join our PIE CLUB and we will email you a coupon for a FREE PIE on your birthday? Stay up to date with Buttermilk Sky Pie news, deals, and get a FREE 4 in. mini pie on your birthday. Talk about a Ha-PIE-Birthday!

Have questions about our pies?

Click here for the most common questions and answers.