For a limited time only

Caramel Turtle Pie is back by popular demand!

This insanely delicious combination of chocolate, caramel and pecans in our shortbread crust will remind you of our chocolate chess pie but it goes the extra mile!

As seen on

Here’s how to get your pie
(and cookies!):

1) Pickup
Call ahead or order online, ring us when you get here, and we will bring your order out to your car.

2) Delivery
Find us on your favorite meal delivery service (Bite Squad, UberEats, Doordash, and Postmates) and your pie will be delivered right to your door.

3) Ship A Pie
Missing a friend or loved one? We can ship a pie directly to them!

As always, remember that sharing pie is sharing love!

Share Pie. Share Love.

Have you ever seen someone receive a pie and not immediately smile? There’s no better way to say you care than with pie. We’d love to help you make someone feel better today.

Birthdays

Anyone can give someone a cake. You want people to know you truly care and think they’re special. A gifted pie lets them know you put thought into their gift.

Event Catering

Your event deserves to be remembered by everyone who was there. An array of pies in any of our nine flavors will make an impression no one can forget.

Business Celebrations

Whether it’s landing the big deal or saying thank you to a client, a fresh baked pie tells those around you how much you value them. Gratitude comes through in the details!

A dessert for every occasion.

With nine daily flavors in three sizes, there’s always something available for when the craving hits.

9-inch pies

Perfect for birthdays family gatherings and corporate gifting.
Serves 7-9

4-inch pies

Great for personal indulgence, gifts, and team celebrations.
Boxed individually, four pack, and by the dozen

2-inch pies

You get three each of Key Lime, Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream, and Peanut Butter Cream packaged together in one box.

Boxed by the dozen

Thumbprint Cookies

Housemade shortbread cookies in vanilla or chocolate with icing that’s perfectly sweet.

Available individually or in packs

Want a free pie?

We believe when you share pie, you share love.

We want to share pie with you - on us! Join our PIE PERKS Club and we will send you a coupon for a FREE 4-inch pie! We’ll also send you news on seasonal offerings and special PIE PERKS deals, including a FREE 4-inch pie on your birthday. That’s a lot of love!

Ready to be introduced to your favorite pie since Grandma’s?

We invite you to enjoy the taste of Southern tradition – the taste of Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop.