We can ship two of our most popular pies to your friends and family across the country:

Nanny’s Pecan Pie and the I-40 Pie.

To ship a pie, please call your local store or fill out the form below.


Important Shipping Information:

We ship Priority Mail to locations anywhere in the lower 48 of the United States for $15/product ordered. Most orders arrive within 2-3 business days.

We use special protective packaging when shipping your handmade pies to keep your pie at peak freshness when it arrives. Buttermilk Sky cannot be held responsible for damages caused by shipper. Buttermilk Sky ships pies to arrive at their destination based on your order date and shipper instructions. Please note we only ship pies out Monday-Wednesday so they reach their destination by the end of the week. Buttermilk Sky cannot be held responsible for late arrivals due to error of shipper.


  • Price: $26.00 Quantity:
    Our classic pecan pie.
  • Price: $26.00 Quantity:
    Our No. 1 best selling southern classic.
  • Price: $20.00 Quantity:
    2-dozen of our signature thumbprint cookies. Handmade shortbread, with our perfectly sweet icing filling.
  • Price: $20.00 Quantity:
    2-dozen of our signature thumbprint cookies. Handmade shortbread, with delicious seasonal filling.
    Current seasonal filling: Winter Mint
  • Order Information

  • Shipping Information

  • Billing Information

  • American Express
  • Price: $0.00
  • $0.00
Refund Policy

We desire for each of our customers to be 100% satisfied with the products they purchase. If for some reason, you are unsatisfied please contact Buttermilk Sky immediately. The store clerks and managers will work together to resolve your case in an individual and timely manner. In some cases, we will offer to fix a mistake, replace a pie, or provide a gift certificate towards a future purchase. However, refunds will not be given.

Shipping Policy

All orders will be processed the next business day Priority Mail via USPS.

*Buttermilk Sky does not ship Thursday – Sunday.

Orders placed on Wednesday will ship on the following Monday or the next business day if Monday is a holiday.

Orders may be delayed to ensure they do not travel over the weekend.

Buttermilk Sky is not responsible for inclement weather or for the arrival of your package beyond providing a tracking number for USPS.