Thumbprint Cookies

Key Lime thumbprint cookies from Buttermilk Sky Pie ShopHappy Summer! And, just like we celebrate Summer with our seasonal pies, we celebrate with our signature thumbprint cookies.

Housemade shortbread, with our perfectly sweet icing filling. 

You’ve heard the old saying, “Sometimes the best things come in small packages.” Well, we certainly believe this proverb goes for our thumbprint cookies. These soft, melt-in-your-mouth cookies are the perfect sweet indulgence when you just want a taste of a special treat.

Although a simple recipe, this classic cookie is one that continually receives rave reviews from our customers. Some cookie connoisseurs like to stop in for a cookie or two on their lunch hour, while others say our thumbprints are a must for any party they have.

And sometimes customers stopping in for pie just can’t resist our cookie display and have to try one on the spot. Often our thumbprint cookies are eaten before customers even reach the door! We take that as the best compliment.

Our thumbprint cookies are versatile too. With each season, we provide different icing colors and flavors to make them festive. These bright and cheerful cookies are a great way to brighten your day or someone else’s.

And, if you’re looking for something lighter after the holiday to indulge in, a thumbprint cookie or two, is a great way to satisfy your sweet tooth.

So, stop in for some thumbprint cookies soon. If you eat them before you reach the door, that’s ok. We won’t tell.

Order Online

Own a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop franchise

Become an owner of America’s fastest-growing pie shop franchise, and bring a taste of Southern tradition to your community.

Learn more

  • Website design: Generator 
  • © 2015 Buttermilk Sky Pies, Knoxville, Tennessee