Order key lime pie online from Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Order Online

Order For Pick-Up

Order ahead, and we'll have your pies ready and waiting for you to pick them up.

Select your preferred pick-up location below.

Colleyville, Texas


Franklin, Tennessee


Johnson City, Tennessee


Knoxville - Bearden


Knoxville - Turkey Creek


Sandy Springs, Georgia


Ship a Pie

We can ship two of our most popular pies to your friends and family across the country, Nanny's Pecan Pie and the I-40 Pie.

Important Shipping Information: All orders are baked and shipped out of Knoxville, Tennessee, and we ship to locations anywhere in the lower 48 of the United States. We use special protective packaging when shipping your handmade pies to keep your pie at peak freshness when it arrives, packing the pies tightly in crinkle cut paper. Buttermilk Sky cannot be held responsible for damages caused by shipper. Buttermilk Sky ships pies to arrive at their destination based on your order date and shipper instructions. Buttermilk Sky cannot be held responsible for late arrivals due to error of shipper.

Ship a Pie

Own a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop franchise

Become an owner of America’s fastest-growing pie shop franchise, and bring a taste of Southern tradition to your community.

Learn more

  • Website design: Generator 
  • © 2015 Buttermilk Sky Pies, Knoxville, Tennessee