Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville, Texas

  • 4712 Colleyville Blvd. Suite 160
  • Colleyville, Texas 76034
  • (817) 581-7437
  • Mon - Thu: 8:30 am – 8 pm
  • Fri - Sat: 8:30 am - 9 pm

Pie it Forward

Each month a share of proceeds from our Pie it Forward pie of the month benefits an organization in our community.

Colleyville's most delicious Southern pie shop!

Pat & Kim Murray, Seth & Katie Hensarling, Owners

Order Online

Receive our Emails


Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville, TexasWe are the Murrays and the Hensarlings - four friends who share a love of family, friendship, pies and people. We are so excited to be the first Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Texas and cannot wait for y’all to taste our scrumptious pies and other tasty treats!

Like many people, we grew up with mothers and grandmothers who baked goodies for holidays, gatherings and carefree afternoons. Days like those hold some of our favorite memories, which is why we decided to open a Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in the charming community of Colleyville, Texas, and provide our customers with the chance to step back in time by enjoying one of our made-from-scratch pies. 

Whether you prefer the traditional slice of a pie, one of our delicious mini-pies, or you're an ice cream fan and love our heavenly Cloud 9, we hope that its sweet, wholesome goodness takes you back to some of your fondest memories.

Hope to see you soon,

Pat & Kim Murray
Seth & Katie Hensarling


Peach Pie Recipe

We recently made a Peach Pie on WFAA in Dallas. While this isn't the Peach Pie we make in the shop, it's still delicious, and easier to make. 

Uber Eats will bring you PiE!

  • Website design: Generator 
  • © 2015 Buttermilk Sky Pies, Knoxville, Tennessee